
We now know, with one exception, which Democratic Senate candidates won by the largest margins. But this metric doesn't actually say which individual candidate did the best (or worst). Sen. Jack Reed (D-RI) won by 38 points, but a random Democrat would probably have done almost as well in Rhode Island because Rhode Island is very, very blue. It is not that Reed is an exceptional candidate (although he is indeed popular with his constituents), it is that Rhode Island is chock-a-block full of Democrats with few Republicans. The Democrats could nominate a yellow dog there and the dog would still win.
A better way to look at individual candidates is to compare how well they did compared to their state's PVI. One new study did precisely that. It appears that the Democrats will win the national two-party popular vote by a staggering 14 points, 57%-43%, when all the votes are counted. This means, for example, that in a state with a PVI of R+2, a generic Republican would be expected to get 43% + 2% = 45% of the vote in the midterms, since the PVI compares a district or state to the country as a whole. A Republican who got, say, 49% last week and lost, still did 6 points better than an average Republican would have done nationally.
To look at a specific example, a generic Democrat in an R+5 state like Florida should have done 5 points worse than the national average (57%) and gotten 52% of the two-party vote statewide. Angie Nixon got only 48.5% of the vote, so she fell 3.5 points short of what a generic Democrat would have gotten. In other words, the numbers say the Democrats would have been better off nominating some random other Democrat rather than Nixon, in which case they would have narrowly won. And she ran against a weak Republican. Any talk of how well Nixon did is not based on facts. In a blue tsunami this big, she should have narrowly won, at least according to the numbers. Put in other terms, Everett Wess, who was crushed in Alabama, was actually a better candidate than Nixon, who merely lost by a little bit. Wess should have been totally obliterated in deep, deep red Alabama. Due to his skills as a candidate, he was merely crushed.
Here is a table of how individual Senate candidates did in the races where the margin was in the single digits (we are including Mary Peltola, and assuming her current margin holds, even though the AP hasn't called the race yet):
| Rank | State | Democrat | PVI | Expected % | Actual % | Diff % |
| 1 | Texas | James Talarico | R+6 | 51% | 56.2% | +5.2% |
| 2 | Mississippi | Scott Colom | R+11 | 46% | 50.1% | +4.1% |
| 3 | North Carolina | Roy Cooper | R+1 | 56% | 60.0% | +4.0% |
| 4 | Kansas | Adam Hamilton | R+8 | 49% | 52.6% | +3.6% |
| 5 (tie) | South Carolina | Annie Andrews | R+8 | 49% | 52.3% | +3.3% |
| 5 (tie) | Alabama | Everett Wess | R+15 | 42% | 45.3% | +3.3% |
| 7 | Louisiana | Jamie Davis | R+11 | 46% | 49.1% | +3.1% |
| 8 | Georgia | Jon Ossoff | R+1 | 56% | 59.0% | +3.0% |
| 9 | Iowa | Josh Turek | R+6 | 51% | 52.1% | +1.1% |
| 10 | Ohio | Sherrod Brown | R+5 | 52% | 52.5% | +0.5% |
| 11 | Nebraska | Dan Osborn | R+10 | 47% | 46.4% | -0.6% |
| 12 | Alaska | Mary Peltola | R+6 | 51% | 50.2% | -0.8% |
| 13 | New Hampshire | Chris Pappas | D+2 | 59% | 57.0% | -2.0% |
| 14 | Michigan | Abdul El-Sayed | EVEN | 57% | 53.6% | -3.4% |
| 15 | Florida | Angie Nixon | R+5 | 52% | 48.5% | -3.5% |
| 16 | Minnesota | Peggy Flanagan | D+3 | 60% | 55.2% | -4.8% |
| 17 | Maine | Troy Jackson | D+4 | 61% | 53.8% | -7.6% |
The light green candidates beat expectations. The brown ones did worse than some random Democrat would be expected to do. So, by this measure, Annie Andrews did 10.9 points better than Troy Jackson. However, when judging candidate quality, it is at least useful to consider the opponent as well. Jackson faced—and beat—one tough old bird in Sen. Susan Collins (R-ME). In South Carolina, Darline Graham is by all evidence a nice person, but a tough young bird she is not. Jackson needs to get a few bonus points for defeating a seasoned veteran, although again, Democrats (or Democrats hiding in independents' clothing) are expected to win Maine. Democrats are expected to be wiped out in South Carolina, and Andrews beat not only Graham, but also the PVI of her state and Jackson didn't. That does speak to both candidates' qualities. (V)