
A really good scandal has sex, money, power and a foreign spy. Nvidia Mobilier has everything. It is going to hang around for a while and be a headache for Donald Trump for months to come. The nature of what actually happened was quite unclear in the beginning, but it is beginning to come more in focus. Maybe after the Democrats hold hearings starting in January we will find out.
The initial take almost everyone had was something like this: China had one of its most attractive professional spies, Alice Huang (actually Huang Le), seduce Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang and then tease all kinds of confidential data from him in bed, which she then reported back to the Chinese Ministry of State Security. In this model, Alice Huang was like Vladimir Putin (formerly a Lt. Colonel in the KGB), a professional spy.
The Chinese Ministry of State Security (MSS) has plenty of professional spies, of course, but what it also does a lot is use opportunist spies. They go to someone who is active and well known in the field they want to spy on and recruit them for a specific mission. Often MSS will use carrots rather than sticks because they believe someone who REALLY REALLY wants the mission to succeed is probably going to do a better job than someone who is nervous and scared to death of being punished if he or she fails.
The initial story may not be what happened exactly. JVL at the Bulwark put together a very plausible scenario that is somewhat different. It goes like this: Jensen Huang very much wants to sell AI chips to anyone with the cash to buy them, friend and foe alike. Who cares about national security? Not his problem. The trouble is that selling advanced chips to China is illegal. Huang has "befriended" Donald Trump in a straightforward way. He had Nvidia donate $25 million to Trump's favorite ballroom. That got Trump's attention and made them buddies. But convincing the mercurial Trump to give him a waiver to bypass the law wasn't easy because Marco Rubio is wildly against selling advanced chips to China.
Enter Huang's Plan B. He got together with Alice Huang, who he knew because she is a "legitimate" customer of Nvidia, buying chips for the AI data center company, Megaspeed, which she used to run, and which she may still have influence in. Together they conspired for Megaspeed to buy chips that she could then resell to Chinese companies. Somehow, in some unexplained way, $3 billion showed up on Megaspeed's books in 2024, up from $33 million in 2023.
This could have been MSS' carrot for Alice Huang. That could have been a loan which would be converted to a grant if the mission was successful. We don't know. The free sex wasn't to seduce Jensen to accidentally give away secrets. It was his reward for doing business with Alice. In this scenario, Jensen and Alice aren't adversaries at all. They are partners trying to get around U.S. export laws. Jensen knows that being duped by an attractive Chinese woman makes him look stupid for thinking with a part of his body other than his brain. But he also knows actively plotting with a Chinese spy to intentionally violate U.S. export laws is 100x worse and is definitely multiple felonies, possibly including treason. That's why he quit. He wanted to try to avoid being in the firing line when the Democrats start investigating this in January. It won't work, but what else could he do now that the chips are out of the bag?
Is this theory correct? It seems to make sense, because Jensen really wants to be able to sell chips to the gigantic Chinese market and U.S. laws prohibit that. So he is running multiple plans simultaneously, bribing Trump, collaborating with a Chinese spy, and maybe more. Who knows? Maybe CIA Director John Ratcliffe, a seasoned pro, knows, but he is certainly not going to talk about it.
But there is more to this story and that is what the Democrats will start with. U.S. intelligence agencies knew that Nvidia had been reporting that 22% of its sales were going to tiny Singapore. Huh? Then last year they changed the way they reported foreign sales to hide the sales to Singapore. This suggests that Jensen Huang knew that U.S. intelligence smelled a rat here and he was trying to cover his tracks.
The Dept. of Commerce had the information from the intelligence agencies and was investigating why 22% of the sales of the top chips were going to Singapore. Then suddenly, someone high up in government transferred the investigation to Todd Blanche's Department of "Justice" where it was immediately killed.
Who done it? Was this Secretary of Commerce Howard Lutnick, acting on his own? It could have been. He has been actively rewriting the export rules for advanced tech, in a manner that would coincidentally mean a windfall for the company he formerly led, Cantor Fitzgerald, which made him worth $7 billion. Cantor is now run by his sons.
Or maybe the order to kill the investigation came from someone even higher up the totem pole than Lutnick. There aren't a lot of people higher up than a cabinet secretary. Although $25 million is peanuts for Donald Trump, it does at least get you small favors. The way things work, Lutnick was not actually carrying out the investigation personally. DoC employees were doing that. It won't be hard for the incoming chairman of the House Oversight Committee, Rep. Robert Garcia (D-CA), to find out who was actually managing the investigation and invite that person over to the Hill for tea and a couple of questions. Like, ferinstance:
Trump is going to travel to China this week. Chinese President Xi Jinping will surely roll out the red carpet, stroke Trump's ego, and maybe give him some made-up Peace Award. It is doubtful Trump will ask any difficult questions or make any threats. He's too (orange) chicken for that.
A couple of Republicans want to investigate Lutnick right now, but there isn't really enough time left in the 119th Congress to do a thorough job. The real work will begin in January when the Democrats take over.
Meanwhile, no story about the administration is good without a little grift. It's part of the package. Here is the stock price for Nvidia (NVDA) for the past 6 months:
The high point of the NVDA stock was $240.68. Friday, it closed at $162.85. That's 32% off the high in 6 weeks. Now, you might be thinking: "With this scandal going full bore, naturally some nervous Nellies will be selling their stock." But look closely and notice the decline began on Oct. 5, 2026. The Times story about Alice Huang was published Oct 29, 2026. That is 24 days after the Nvidia stock price started its precipitous drop. There was no public news about Nvidia on Oct. 5 that might have caused its stock to plunge, but if any wealthy insiders knew about what was about to come out, they could have made bank by shorting NVDA big time. The large surge in selling NVDA then could have triggered the price drop. Just askin' questions, that's all. We question, you decide. (V)