
CNN had a pretty big story over the weekend, one that got somewhat lost because it WAS the weekend, and because attention was on other stories, like the airplanes being grounded. But according to numerous insiders, J.D. Vance is thinking carefully about whether or not 2028 is really his year, and whether it makes sense for him to run for president at that time.
As a purely tactical matter, running in 2028 is almost certainly Vance's best opportunity to secure the Republican nomination. He will never be higher-profile than he is as the sitting VP. And he will never have an easier time of getting the GOP machinery aligned in his favor. There are plenty of VPs who exit the political stage and are quickly rendered impotent. For a recent example, see Mike Pence's 2024 presidential campaign, which was so anemic that it did not actually last into the calendar year 2024 (he suspended on October 28, 2023).
The problem, and Vance is mare than smart enough to know this, is that running in 2028 is almost certainly NOT his best opportunity to actually become president. We see three particular issues for him that make victory... improbable in 2028. The first is the godawful presidential track record of sitting VPs. Here is a rundown of all sitting VPs who have run since the year 1900:
| Year | VP | Result |
| 1908 | Charles W. Fairbanks | Not nominated |
| 1920 | Thomas R. Marshall | Not nominated |
| 1952 | Alben W. Barkley | Not nominated |
| 1960 | Richard Nixon | Lost election |
| 1968 | Hubert Humphrey | Lost election |
| 1988 | George H.W. Bush | Won election |
| 2000 | Al Gore | Lost election |
| 2024 | Kamala Harris | Lost election |
For those who were not math majors, sitting VPs have a .125 batting average since 1900. And it drops to .111 if you include Joe Biden in 2016, who certainly wanted to run, but was talked out of it by Barack Obama, so Hillary Clinton could have the Obama lane to herself.
And that brings us to the second problem. The reason that VPs have such a poor track record is that they cannot avoid being joined at the hip with the president whom they served alongside. That was a real problem for five of the seven losers listed above; they were connected to presidents who were damaged by things like the post-World War I upheavals, a weak economy, Vietnam, or sex scandals. Think of that. Al Gore lost because Bill Clinton had a zipper management problem with a consenting straight adult woman who wanted the affair. How can any sane person blame Gore for that? It wasn't that people didn't Clinton's policies (which Gore had to support). It was Clinton's personal conduct that hurt Gore even though he had no scandals at all.
A sixth is Fairbanks, whose president (Theodore Roosevelt) was popular, but who had the bad luck that he was not the chosen successor (William Howard Taft was). And then there's the one winner, Bush, whose president (Ronald Reagan) left office with very high approval ratings. That allowed Bush Sr. to buck the trend.
Vance has unusually difficult challenge here. Using Gallup, because their data covers the entire polling age, Reagan left office with a 63% approval rating. Trump is currently the mirror image of that—36%. There is no plausible world in which Trump rebounds to Reagan-like numbers. In fact, thanks to the chaos in the administration (see above), and the possibility that the Iran War and the bad economic times linger, Trump is far more likely to dip into the 20s than he is to get back into the 50s (much less the 60s).
Vance could theoretically try to put space between himself and Trump, but there is no way that will work (unless Vance resigns, and even then it's only a maybe). Part of the reason we say it won't work is because it never works. You can't run on your experience and wisdom as VP, while at the same time badmouthing the administration that gave you that experience and wisdom. The other part of the reason that it won't work is because Trump, who is the most thin-skinned president of the last half-century, might take any "distancing" as an insult, and might turn against Vance as a result. Just yesterday, Vance offered an object lesson in this phenomenon when he did an interview with Fox "News," and insisted that there is "no daylight" between him and Trump on the Iran War. Recall that this is the same Iran War that is probably the single most unpopular policy of the Trump administration, and that Vance himself blamed for the Republicans' electoral drubbing.
And that brings us to the third problem, which is Vance himself. We had a letter this weekend from reader R.P. in Vashon, who argued that Vance is actually a very talented politician, that our consistent criticism of him is misplaced, and that "He is an agile, disciplined, and dangerous operator, and failing to treat him as such only clears his runway to 2028."
R.P. is right... and wrong. It is certainly true that Vance is a skilled political operator; you do not rise from "private citizen" to "Vice President of the United States" in just 2 years without that being the case. However, it is also certainly true that he is wildly unpopular, with a net approval rating of -12. That's very, very bad for a VP, especially since Vance got there because 52% of voters do not approve of him (which means 40% like what they see). Most VPs are semi-anonymous, such that a big chunk of the electorate doesn't have an opinion. But only 8% haven't formed an opinion on Vance, which means he's starting in a "the majority doesn't like me" hole, and he doesn't have an obvious path to improvement. This is not surprising, because he's weird, and he's not charismatic, and he's not a great public speaker, and his chameleon act is not nearly as subtle as he thinks it is.
We addressed seven of the seven of the eight VPs who tried to run for president above; a comparison to the eighth—Richard Nixon—could be instructive here. Nixon, like Vance, was a venal and self-interested man, and more than willing to do whatever was needed to achieve power. Nixon, like Vance, was odd-looking, lacked charisma, and was not a great public speaker. And Nixon had a very similar career path—he served 4 years in the House (which Vance did not, obviously), then 2 years in the Senate, and then was elected VP.
The situation that Nixon faced in 1960 is different from the one that Vance would probably face in 2028. Dwight D. Eisenhower was popular, unlike Trump. That said, he denigrated Nixon's service in the administration, famously telling a reporter that he would need a week to come up with an important contribution that the VP had made. So, the presidential coattails weren't quite as long as they might have been. Anyhow, Nixon might plausibly have pulled it off, and it was certainly a very close election, but in the end, he lost.
At that point, and in particular after following that with a loss in the 1962 California gubernatorial election, Tricky Dick concluded that Richard Nixon v1.0—red-baiting Communist witch hunter—which had served him so well, needed to be retired. The Cold War was thawing a fair bit by the early 1960s. So, he disappeared for a few years, and spent that time reinventing himself as a wise elder statesman who could be trusted to find accommodation with the communists, particularly in China. It worked, of course, though it certainly also helped that when he ran in 1968, he was up against a VP joined at the hip with the wildly unpopular Lyndon B. Johnson.
In any event, if Vance decides to strike while the iron is hot in 2028, we can certainly understand his thinking, though it will almost certainly end in disaster. Alternatively, he's still young (42), and there's time enough for him to go away for a good, long while, and to re-emerge as a different J.D. Vance (though in his case, it would be more like Vance v7.0, not Vance v2.0). We think the evidence is strong that is his only real path to the White House. And given his hemming and hawing about a 2028 run (at least, behind the scenes), we imagine he agrees, even if he would prefer that was not the case.
And let us point out, finally, that Vance's (possible) change of heart might explain Marco Rubio's choice, which we wrote about yesterday, to hug Trump closer, as opposed to resigning and trying to create some distance between himself and an unpopular administration. There is GOING to be a candidate in the MAGA lane in 2028, and whether they get the nomination or not, they are going to hang on for a very long time. If Vance abandons that lane for now, then Rubio would be far and away the favorite to become the MAGA champion. It's not a great path to the White House, for the reasons we outline above, But he's not a very imaginative fellow, and he's a fair bit older than Vance (55), so the Secretary might think it's his very best chance. (Z)