
We have many reports from readers addressing developments that are local to them. It took us a while to organize them all, but that work is finally done, and have roughly a dozen collections of letters we'll run over the next few weeks. Today, we are going to start with a couple of messages from readers that speak to how important it is that voters feel they have a voice:
S.G. in Newark, NJ: I thought I'd share a tidbit from Essex County, NJ, a few miles west of New York City.
Overall, Essex County is very densely populated (nearly 900,000 people living in 130 square miles), majority-minority (the Census Bureau says about one-third of the population is non-Latino white), and somewhat economically disadvantaged (countywide median household income around $80K). Not surprisingly, Democrats dominate the county's politics.
But not everywhere. Towns on the county's western edge are, generally, less densely populated, whiter, wealthier, and more Republican than the rest of the county. Your readers may have heard of one of these towns: North Caldwell, one of New Jersey's most affluent municipalities, which famously was the location of Tony Soprano's home.
Several of these towns held elections for mayor and council members this year. In Caldwell (from which North Caldwell, West Caldwell and other towns seceded long ago in a 19th-century tax revolt) the voters replaced the incumbent Republican mayor, voting 52% to 48% for his Democratic opponent. By similar margins, the Democrats retained two council seats that they had won by single digits three years ago. (Yes, Caldwell council terms are three years, and the other four seats are held by Republicans).
I think this little municipal election tells us something. In Essex County, there was absolutely no suspense about this year's races at the top or even in the middle of the ticket. Sen. Cory Booker (D) was reelected with 63% of the vote. All three incumbent Democratic House of Representatives members whose districts include parts of Essex County won reelection by at least 22 points. All the Democratic candidates for County Executive and Board of County Commissioners (our legislative body) received at least four times as many votes as their Republican opponents (if they had a Republican opponent at all). Yet, in a town of 9,000 people, 3,200—more than half of those registered—turned out to vote and handed their local Democratic candidates a four-percentage-point victory. To me, that speaks volumes about how desperately people wanted their voices heard this year.
Incidentally, in North Caldwell, which had a Democratic mayor and an evenly-divided council, the parties cut a deal during primary season. The Democrats did not run a mayoral candidate, and in return, the Republicans did not run a candidate for the two council seats that were up, which had also been held by Democrats. Because the mayor casts tie-breaking votes, the Republicans functionally have the majority in North Caldwell. Wonder if the local Democratic party now regrets that deal.
J.A. in Manchester, NH: It was very satisfying to see the American people remember that they actually DO have a say in who will run things for them.
As incredible as Tuesday's results were at the federal level, what I'm finding even more fascinating is the state house flips. Here in New Hampshire, the Democrats look to be on track to take 290 of the 400 House seats. Not a bad result when they were in the minority since 2020. In the 25-seat senate, the blue team is one win away from a veto-proof majority (at this time; one race may be headed for a recount). Before Tuesday, the red team had the veto-proof majority.
Gov. Kelly Ayotte (R) won a second term, but had Cinde Warmington (D) been better funded and not had the albatross of being a Purdue Pharma lawyer back in the day around her neck, the governor's office would likely have flipped as well.
All in all, a stunning reminder of what happens in a representative republic when people exercise their right to pick their own leaders.
Tomorrow's entry, which will most certainly feature a larger number of letters, will be about U.S. Senate seats that might be in play in 2028. If readers have any thoughts on that subject, please send them to comments@electoral-vote.com. (Z)