
We've been waiting for 2 weeks, and now it's AP-official: Democrat Mary Peltola is a senator-elect, having defeated Sen. Dan Sullivan (R-AK). She also defeated Dan Sullivan (R?), as well.
It's not just the AP that called the race; in short order, NBC News, Decision Desk, CNN and The New York Times, among others, made the call. That is presumably because, in the latest update, Peltola finally crossed the 50% threshold. She is currently at 50.1%, with a lead of about 12,500 votes over the Sullivan who is a senator, and with only 1,800 votes remaining to be counted. Or, if you add the remaining votes plus the votes for the other Sullivan and for Gerald Heikes (R), it totals about 12,500 votes. So, even if every vote that could possibly become a Sen. Sullivan vote does become a Sen. Sullivan vote, she still wins.
We still don't entirely understand why it took so long to call the race. The standard for making a call is something like "It is not mathematically plausible for the outcome of this race to change." It is NOT "It is mathematically impossible for the outcome of this race to change." It has been entirely implausible for anyone other than Peltola to win for at least 3 days. She's been all over Twitter pointing that out. Further, and we did not know this until reader B.H. in Florence, OR brought it to our attention, Alaska has been releasing preliminary ranked-choice totals. It's been known for days that a fair chunk of the Sullivan/Heikes ballots would become Peltola votes, and that she was in line to ultimately end up with about 52% of the vote. In other words, even if the standard WAS "It is mathematically impossible for the outcome of this race to change," the data needed to make that determination has been available for at least the last several days.
There is one other semi-interesting thing that will likely escape notice, because the ranked-choice ballots are not going to be officially processed or announced. Peltola, as noted, was in line to finish just shy of 52% of the vote. Gov.-elect Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins (D) was in line to finish a shade north of 57%. Normally, one would expect the name candidate (i.e, the well-known former representative Peltola) to be the one to put up the bigger margin of victory. We are not in Alaska, so we do not know what happened here. Was it because Peltola was up against an incumbent and Kreiss-Tomkins was not? Because of the fake Sullivan stunt? Because people are more comfortable electing a governor of a different party than a senator of a different party? Because of sexism? Some or all of the above? If any readers have insight, we would welcome it at comments@electoral-vote.com.
Meanwhile, we think we should make a brief mention of the midterm elections that took place in 1958. Why 1958? Because that is the last time the Democrats flipped 9 or more seats. In fact, in that year, the blue team flipped a staggering 13 seats, and they netted a total of 15, That turned what had been a 50-45 Democratic majority (with one vacancy) into a 64-34 Democratic majority.
How can such carnage be explained? Well, there are a few factors. Although President Dwight D. Eisenhower was personally popular, the voting public nonetheless had a pretty serious case of six-year-itch. They were not thrilled about a poor economy, or about an unduly harsh border policy. Some of them did not care for the sitting vice president, who was a literal Dick, and wanted to suggest that maybe he shouldn't run in 1960. Perhaps most importantly, a lot of voters were tired of the racism that was deeply embedded in some elements of the incumbent's party. And so, a bunch of states that had been reliably red for generations, mostly in the Northeast, decided to send Democrats to Washington. Oh, and those last two seats, the ones that were the icing on the cake, were the two newly created seats representing the brand-new state of... Alaska. These 15 freshman Democrats became the backbone of the coalition that would enact the Great Society legislation half a decade later.
In other words, the last time the Democrats did this well, it was the start of a serious party realignment, and one that created a window for some serious reform. Could it happen again? It is certainly possible. (Z)