Dem 56
image description
   
GOP 44
image description

Introducing the Vibes Index

The Washington Sun (formerly NOTUS) is a start-up online-only newspaper that has ambitions to overtake The Washington Post and become D.C.'s main paper. When the Post fired a large number of reporters, the Sun scooped up many of them to give it an experienced staff right off the bat. It also hosts many "fellows" who are recent college graduates, for 24-month stints with the Sun. The fellows are paid $60,000/year, to ensure a long list of applicants. The goal is to build a pipeline of investigative journalists for the future. The project is the brainchild of Robert Allbritton, who founded Politico in 2007.

The staff at the Sun know that polls and money don't measure everything during the invisible primary, the 2028 edition of which started on Nov. 4. They know some candidates are "hot" and others are not, and that matters because donors, potential campaign staff, pollsters, volunteers and others can feel that and like to join up early with a winner. To try to measure who is "hot" at the moment—something that can change on a dime—they assembled a panel of 60 D.C. insiders who have a good "feel" for politics and politicians. The panel includes politicians, reporters, campaign operatives, writers, pundits, political scientists and others. Every month they will be asked for the 10 hottest presidential candidates in both parties, giving #1 10 points, #2 9 points, down to #10 with 1 point. The idea is that the panel can take into account things like "everybody is talking about [X]," which polls don't. The polls just measure name recognition at this point and that will change radically when candidates announce and start actually holding rallies.

Of course, the insiders sometimes get it wrong, but they also see stuff that casual observers miss, like a candidate's fiery temper, inability to manage a staff, or boring speaking style. The paper has just published its November winners. The ranking is based on the numerical score, but for additional context, the Sun is also reporting the number of first-place votes the candidate got, the number of "voters" who left the candidate off the ballot altogether, what the polls say, what the prediction market odds are, and ranking in terms of Wikipedia visits to their page. Here is the November ranking:

Democrats
Rank Candidate #Firsts #Left offs Polls Odds Wiki rank
1 Jon Ossoff 37 1 9% .26 1
2 Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez 1 5 12% .15 3
3 Pete Buttigieg 1 1 13% .05 4
4 Josh Shapiro 5 4 5% .05 7
5 Gavin Newsom 2 8 14% .10 2
6 JB Pritzker 4 12 3% .02 6
7 Wes Moore 0 12 1% .02 10
8 Andy Beshear 1 9 3% .04 8
9 Mark Kelly 2 11 7% .03 9
10 Kamala Harris 2 25 22% .05 5

The third column (#Firsts) is how many of the 60 panelists put the candidate first. For example. Jon Ossoff was rated the hottest by 37 panelists—more than half. That's more than everyone else combined. Boy is he hot, despite saying he won't run. That's what happens when you win a Southern swing state by 18 points.

The fourth column (#Left offs) is how many times the candidate was left off someone's list—that is, didn't even make the top 10. Here, Kamala Harris takes the cake. Twenty-five of the panelists didn't think she was hot enough to make the top 10. And it wasn't a bias against women of color, because another woman of color was #2.

The fifth column (Polls) is how the candidate is doing in the polls. The sixth column (Odds) is the probability from the prediction markets The seventh column (Wiki) ranks how the candidate stacks up on Wikipedia searches.

Now a few words about the candidates. Ossoff was the odds-on winner. He is the golden boy for the moment. Political operatives are begging to be on his staff, even though he said he wasn't running. Maybe he means it, but as readers know, every morning approximately 100 U.S. senators look in the bathroom mirror and see a future president. Most of them are delusional. But of the 330 million people in the U.S., the person with the highest probability of being elected president in 2028 is likely Jon Ossoff. That's hard to resist. The vibe was: Hotticus Finch.

While other candidates are scrounging for a base and a platform, AOC has both already and is ready to go. But she has a different problem than the others. In reality, the chance of her being elected president is probably pretty low. Only one House member ever did it, she is very young, and gravitas is not her strength. On the other hand, while she is not a shoo-in for U.S. senator from New York, she almost is, and running for president after a term or two in the Senate would greatly increase her chances. Tough call (not really). The vibe was: I will be deliberating this privately.

Mayor Pete (and Secretary Pete) could have been governor of Michigan or a senator from Michigan and didn't try. He really wants to be president. He's been going around the country like crazy campaigning—nominally for other Democrats, but not entirely. The vibe: Doing the work.

Josh Shapiro now runs the trifecta in Pennsylvania. His first 100 days at that could be a dry run for his first 100 days in the White House. If he gets a ton of stuff done, he will soar. The vibe: Watch this space.

Gavin Newsom did a great job re-gerrymandering his state, he defeated the wealth tax on billionaires (which will not go over well with lefties) and he really gets under Trump's skin. So why did he get only two first-place votes? Maybe because he is as slimy as a snake, with is the direct opposite of "authentic," which voters like. The vibe: Not 2025 anymore.

Coming in sixth could be good for JB Pritzker. While the top five will be under a microscope and taking a lot of flak, he can quietly organize his campaign, especially since money won't be a problem for this billionaire. The vibe: It's not like he has to worry about fundraising.

It wasn't a good year for Wes Moore. His redistricting battle failed. The year before, a boat took out the Key Bridge in Baltimore and he didn't get it fixed fast. He got 0 first place votes, so definitely a sleeper candidate. The vibe: Try our new and improved recipe.

As chairman of the Democratic Governors Association, Andy Beshear's candidates won a lot of governorships. But he ignored Texas. People won't forget that after they learn who he is. The vibe: Putting the blues in "bluenami."

Mark Kelly knows that one of the early nominating states, New Mexico, is in his neck of the woods arid desert. He's a tough guy and a combat veteran and a former astronaut. He knows no fear, certainly not of Pete Hegseth. The vibe: Knows how to go up quickly.

Finally, Kamala Harris. Twenty-five people didn't even put her in the top 10. Terrible. She is well known, but that advantage will fade fast once the campaign heats up and other candidates start campaigning and getting attention. No one thinks she has any rizz. There is a whole bench of up-and-coming much younger candidates. If the voters want a Black candidate, Wes Moore is newer and fresher. And she lost to a horrible candidate in 2024. The vibe: Even Brat Summer is followed by a fall.

Despite the shellacking on Nov. 3, the Republican Party still exists and has a number of members who would dearly love to be president. Who is vibey? Let's see:

Republicans
Rank Candidate #Firsts #Left offs Polls Odds Wiki rank
1 Marco Rubio 28 2 26% .17 5
2 Ron DeSantis 7 1 9% .15 3
3 J.D. Vance 13 1 37% .35 2
4 Ted Cruz 1 6 3% .03 4
5 Glenn Youngkin 1 6 1% .03 10
6 Josh Hawley 1 10 2% .01 9
7 Tucker Carlson 5 15 2% .04 8
8 Sarah Huckabee Sanders 0 18 1% .01 7
9 Byron Donalds 0 22 -- .01 1
10 Nikki Haley 1 27 4% .01 6

According to the insiders, it will be Ossoff vs. Marco Rubio, a generational shift. Rubio is by far the favorite here for the GOP nomination. A lot could depend on whether the war in Iran is ongoing and whether Rubio gets the blame for it. The insiders are certainly aware that Trump is increasingly annoyed by Vance trying to distance himself from the war. If Vance keeps this up, Trump may ultimately bestow his blessings on Rubio, ending Vance's career in one blow. All of Peter Thiel's money will have gone for nought. Trump's own advisers and donors have also long been telling him that Rubio is by far the stronger candidate of the two. The vibe: Anything you can do, I can do better

Ron DeSantis got seven first-place votes and was left off only one ballot. Florida was the one state where Republicans didn't get wiped out on Nov. 3 and DeSantis will trumpet that for all to hear. If Republicans really get tired of D.C. and everyone there, DeSantis is the obvious choice. He is MAGA but also an outsider. If Trump supports Rubio, it could come down to Rubio vs. DeSantis. Depending on how unpopular Trump is, this could get very interesting. The vibe: This could be us, but you playin'.

With 13 first-place votes, J.D. Vance is the heir apparent. But sitting vice presidents don't have a good track record and certainly not if they are joined at the hip to an unpopular president (who is probably going to get even worse in the next few months if he starts defying Congress and the courts on subpoenas). The war in Iran is like an albatross around his neck and it shows no indication of flying off to greener pastures waters. The vibe: The heir apparent...ly not so simple.

We are surprised that Ted Cruz got one first-place vote. Maybe that "voter" thinks the top three all have serious problems and he is the only somewhat serious candidate left, despite the fact that all 99 of the other senators despise Cruz as a show horse and the Texas voters only voted for him due to that (R) after his name. A big problem for Cruz that is not of his making is that if he is elected president, Gov. Gina Hinojosa (D-TX) will choose his successor, flipping another Senate seat. The vibe: Blue lagooned?

We expected Gov. Brian Kemp (R-GA) as #4 or 5, but no, it is Glenn Youngkin, with one first-place vote. One problem is that he probably can't even win his home state of Virginia. He wants to be a Romneyier Trump, but he is probably a Trumpier Romney. The vibe: Vested and ready.

Josh Hawley is a fresh face. If the early momentum on the other side is all with Ossoff, the Republicans may decide they need a fresh young guy, too, and Hawley fits the bill. Being low on the list out of the gate gives him time to organize his campaign quietly out of the spotlight so if everyone above him fails, he's ready to stop in. The vibe: Pinch hitter.

Tucker Carlson??? This is as nutty as Donald Trump in 2016. And we all know how that worked out. But do the Republican voters really want to move hard right after Nov. 3? The vibe: What are we doing? What's going on?

Sarah Huckabee Sanders got 0 first-place votes and was left off 18 ballots. The panelists clearly are desperate because they were told to list 10 people and they ran out after about seven. The vibe: More to be revealed.

Byron Donalds scored worse than Sanders, with 0 first-place votes and left off 22 ballots. He's Black and Republicans are the favored party of white supremacists. Also, he is just now in the spotlight. The vibe: The next Florida man.

Finally, Nikki Haley. She did get one first-place vote. If MAGA totally collapses in the next 2 years and Republicans really want to move on to something completely different and are willing to tolerate a woman at that, then maybe. Otherwise, no thank you. The vibe: Literally: Also (she) ran.

There you have it. As we have pointed out a couple of times before, in politics, a week is a long time. But it will be interesting to see how candidates move up and down the list with each month's new list. Insiders are hardly infallible but they are less swayed by name recognition than voters responding to polls. However, we do find it odd that Sen. Ruben Gallego (D-AZ) and Gov. Brian Kemp (R-GA) didn't make the lists. We would have put them on somewhere. (V)



This item appeared on www.electoral-vote.com. Read it Monday through Friday for political and election news, Saturday for answers to reader's questions, and Sunday for letters from readers.

www.electoral-vote.com                     State polls                     All Senate candidates