Dem 56
image description
   
GOP 44
image description

Legal News: The NPVIC Is Not Unconstitutional, Per Se

The Electoral College has long been a thorn in the side of many people who believe it undermines democracy, in that the popular vote winner of America's presidential contest doesn't always become president. As has been discussed many times here and elsewhere, it also creates an incentive to concentrate all of a candidate's resources on a small number of "swing" states, despite the fact that their population or demographics may not merit such outsized attention. All other states, meanwhile, are largely ignored by presidential candidates, since they use a winner-take-all system to award electoral votes and the results are usually a foregone conclusion. This can depress voter turnout.

The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact (NPVIC) is a simple idea, whereby states pledge to award their electoral votes to the national popular vote winner, regardless of how their individual state votes. So, if this were in place in 2000, for example, Indiana, which voted for George W. Bush, would have awarded its electoral votes to Al Gore, the national popular vote winner. This would have resulted in Gore becoming president and we could have avoided learning about Florida's hanging chads and the Brooks Brothers riot.

So far, 18 states and D.C. have signed on, amounting to 222 electoral votes. The NPVIC takes effect once enough states sign on to get to 270 electoral votes. With the midterm election, there are five more states likely to sign on, any four of which would cross the 270 line: Arizona, Michigan, Nevada, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin. All of these states will have a Democratic trifecta come January 2027.

There are some potential legal issues with this idea, however. And since Republicans have not fully embraced the NPVIC—although Republican-led chambers in New York, Oklahoma and Arizona joined the compact—they are likely to bring some legal challenges to its implementation. Now, if Republicans believe that Texas is really going blue, that could change their thinking on this subject, since that would put the GOP's biggest, safest repository of EVs in doubt, and might mean that a popular-vote victory is their best (and maybe only) path to winning the White House. Nonetheless, let's run through some of the potential hurdles.

The Elections Clause, in Article II, Section 1, of the U.S. Constitution, says:

Each State shall appoint, in such Manner as the Legislature thereof may direct, a Number of Electors, equal to the whole number of Senators and Representatives to which the State may be entitled in the Congress..."

The section goes on to detail how the electors meet and how to tally their votes, including that "they shall make a List of all the Persons voted for, and of the Number of Votes for each; which List they shall sign and certify, and transmit sealed to the Seat of the Government of the United States, directed to the President of the Senate." Given that the section allows the legislature to determine the "manner" in which the electors are appointed, many argue that electors can be instructed to vote for the winner of the national popular vote, regardless of the state's results. The Supreme Court has definitely held that the legislature can require electors to vote based on the state's popular vote. But it's still an open question whether the legislature can require electors to ignore the state's popular vote and only follow the national vote.

There's also the Compact Clause of Article I, Section X. However, if this came into play due to lawsuits, it would not prohibit states from entering into the NPVIC. It would just require Congressional approval. Interestingly, the president's sign-off is probably not required, though John Roberts and his band of merry men (and one merry woman) would undoubtedly get the final say.

Aside from the possibility of legal challenges, there are also other arguments for choosing less dramatic reforms to the current system. Theodore Johnson proposes that the problems the NPVIC is designed to address can be fixed with a simpler, more straightforward solution. The issue with the NPVIC is it requires state legislatures to, in some cases, ignore their residents' choice for president. While the U.S. elects a president to serve the nation, it's still a collection of states with their own sovereignty and plenary power. One can imagine that residents of the states that choose a president who doesn't win the national popular vote might not be so thrilled to have their votes cast for someone else.

Johnson proposes that instead of ignoring those votes, states should elevate them and award their electoral votes proportionally, instead of winner-take-all. In other words, if Jon Ossoff wins 60% of the vote in California and Marco Rubio wins 40%, then Jon Ossoff gets 60% of the votes, while the 40% minority still gets a voice in the presidential contest, as they will end up awarding about 21 EVs to Rubio. This approach would require candidates to campaign in more states and districts, and would also ensures that the winning candidate has a majority of the nation's voting population. As Johnson notes, "That approach would mean that when choosing a president, both people and states—twin pillars of the republic—count."

This alternative approach is not perfect, mind you. Since EVs would be rounded, it could produce wonky results in very close elections (say, like the one in 1960). Further, while candidates would no longer be incentivized to lavish most of their attention on Michigan and Nevada, they would be incentivized to focus almost entirely on high-population urban areas.

That said, the political problem with the NPVIC—which the folks who created the idea did not anticipate—is that if and when it comes into force, it will do so almost entirely with the backing of blue states. Except for Oklahoma, even those states where a Republican legislature approved the pact are blue now. The primary value of the alternative approach, then, might be as a compromise measure. Democrats could say: "We've got he NPVIC, and we think we can defend it in court, but we are also willing to enact the alternative if Republicans will support it."

We're putting the cart ahead of the horse here a little, since the NPVIC hasn't actually been approved by the necessary number of states, nor have Republicans made clear they will resist it. Still, it can't hurt to know the lay of the land as this story unfolds next year. (L & Z)



This item appeared on www.electoral-vote.com. Read it Monday through Friday for political and election news, Saturday for answers to reader's questions, and Sunday for letters from readers.

www.electoral-vote.com                     State polls                     All Senate candidates