Dem 56
image description
   
GOP 44
image description

Saturday Q&A

We are going to hold off on the reader question of the week today. First, because it doesn't line up well with non-politics questions. Second, because we are taking Thanksgiving weekend off. The "What should the Democrats do first?" answers were so numerous, we have loosely organized them into four sets. It will be good, we think, to run those on consecutive weekends in December, such that the last installment runs just days before the new Congress takes its seats.

Anyhow, as noted, it's non-politics day. And by that, we mean that we're deferring questions about present-day politics. Historical questions about politics are still fair game.

And for those who are still working on the headline theme, we will again note that we usually start with the toughest headline of the day, and work from there. For example, two weeks ago, we had to use "Nvidia" in a headline, and so developed the theme around that necessity. Yesterday, we had a similar item. And then, due to time and length constraints, we had to hold that item (we don't know that will happen until long after the headline theme has been set and the headlines have all been written). That item is still going to run, next week, and it will still carry the same headline, which was and is "Senatus Populusque Americanus."

On to the questions and answers:

 

J.G. in Inver Grove Heights, MN, asks: I find curiosity to be a grossly underappreciated quality in people. Who do you think were the five most curious U.S. presidents?

(Z) answers: Naturally, a lot more is known about the proclivities of the more famous presidents, and the more recent presidents. So, it's possible that one of the more obscure 19th century presidents was just an intellectual dynamo, but that it's unknown. That said, here are five pretty good answers, in chronological order:

  1. Thomas Jefferson: If you look up "polymath" in the dictionary, his picture should be there (perhaps alongside that of his buddy, Benjamin Franklin). Jefferson explored seriously every branch of knowledge that was known in his day, and of course made serious contributions as a politician, political theorist, architect, theologian and scientist, and more modest contributions as an inventor, economist and biologist.

  2. Abraham Lincoln: He does not quite fit the mold of the other four fellows on this list. He was not particularly concerned with breadth of knowledge (especially since he lived in the sticks, where books were scarce). He was also not exactly concerned with depth of knowledge (i.e., completely mastering the contemporary thinking on law). What he did focus on was depth of understanding. He would study the same texts, over and over, until he felt he knew and understood them inside and out. In particular, he devoted much attention to Blackstone's Commentaries on law, the collected works of William Shakespeare, and the Bible. I think that counts as a form of curiosity, especially given Lincoln's general lack of access to information.

  3. Theodore Roosevelt: Another polymath who read and wrote widely, and was, like Winston Churchill, a serious historian in addition to being a high-level politician.

  4. Bill Clinton: Reportedly, he speed-reads, and he devours books on a broad variety of topics. There are many stories about him having postdoc-level conversations with people in various fields of endeavor. For example, Stephen Hawking once visited the Oval Office, and expected a bunch of lightweight questions from Bubba. Instead, once he was able to turn his attention to Hawking, Clinton rattled off a series of inquiries that Hawking described as worthy of "an experienced physicist."

  5. Barack Obama: This may be a product of recency bias, since we know so much more about Obama's avocations than we do about those of, say, John Tyler. That said, Obama has always displayed a broad variety of knowledge. And the book/music/film lists he releases regularly speak to someone who samples from a broad variety of disciplines and styles.

Also warranting serious consideration, in chronological order of service: John Adams, James Madison, John Quincy Adams, James Garfield, Herbert Hoover, John F. Kennedy, Richard Nixon and Jimmy Carter.


 

M.R. in Washington, DC, asks: With the non-Obama ex presidents getting up in age, there is a chance the next president could have only one living predecessor. Aside from the early days of our country, has there ever been only 1 (or 0) living ex-presidents?

(Z) answers: Let us assume the next president serves two terms, commencing on January 20, 2029, and concluding on January 20, 2037. Joe Biden would be 95 by then, and the three presidents born in 1946 (Bill Clinton, George W. Bush and Donald Trump) would all be roughly 91. The last four presidents to die (in order, Ronald Reagan, Gerald Ford, George H.W. Bush and Jimmy Carter) all made it to 91 and then some, and one of them made it to 95 and then some, so the odds are pretty good that at least one non-Obama president will still be kicking on January 20, 2037. The odds get better, obviously, if you assume that the next president serves only one term, or that the next president serves only the balance of Donald Trump's current term.

That said, we will accept your premise for purposes of this answer. Besides George Washington, there have been five presidents who served some amount of time where only one other former president was alive: John Adams (Washington), Ulysses S. Grant (A. Johnson), Theodore Roosevelt (Cleveland), Herbert Hoover (Coolidge) and Richard Nixon (L. Johnson). In each of those five cases, the former president died while the "only one living predecessor" president was still in office, leaving them as the sole living holder of the presidency for the balance of their terms.

Because none of these five (or six) men died during their terms, nobody has ever been the only living president or ex-president from the moment they assumed the office.


 

M.D. in San Tan Valley, AZ, asks: After seeing the huge upset Senate win for Scott Colom in Mississippi, it looks like Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith's (R-MS) comment of "pick another protein" really shifted the election against her and for Colom. This reminded me of the Senate election of 2006, when then-senator George Allen of Virginia pointed at a staffer of his opponent, Jim Webb, who was of Indian descent and was filming Allen's event, and called him "macaca."

Obviously, in both cases, this cost them their incumbent Senate seats. So, I wanted to know if you can think of a few more really good "slip of the tongue" catastrophes that have also sent an election frontrunner to a shocking defeat.

(Z) answers: The most famous incident of this sort in U.S. history came on October 29, 1884, and the ill-advised comment was not actually made by the candidate himself. Presbyterian minister Samuel D. Burchard, of New York City, was trying to rally votes for Republican James G. Blaine. In a speech/sermon, Burchard slurred Grover Cleveland and his Democratic colleagues, accusing them of being the party of "rum, Romanism, and rebellion." This outraged Irish-American voters in New York City, and they made damn sure to get to the polls. Cleveland ended up winning New York by just 1,149 votes. And New York's 36 EVs were decisive, as the Electoral College went 219-182 for the Democrat. If the Empire State had gone the other way, it would have been 218-183 for Blaine.

Of more recent vintage are the various ill-advised comments about rape. In 1990, Clayton Williams probably cost himself the governorship of Texas when he advised rape victims that they "might as well lay back and enjoy it." In 2012, Todd Akin certainly cost himself a Senate seat in Missouri when he said that victims of "legitimate rape" rarely get pregnant. In 2022, Ed Thelander probably blew his chances to win the very red ME-01 when he decreed that the NOAA wants to "rape you and your family." And in that same year, Michigan state Senate candidate Robert Regan repeated the Williams line about "enjoying it" and threw away an election he was heavily favored to win.

There are examples of politicians in Europe who decided to make snarky jokes about the Nazis, and it cost them their jobs, or their election. In the U.S., there have been politicians (particularly recently) who embraced Nazism in one way or another—often not jokingly—but it would be hard to say any of those folks were favored to win. Mostly, they were fringy types who claimed a nomination nobody else wanted in a district that heavily favored the other party. I suppose you could say that Graham Platner was the frontrunner, but it wasn't just the Nazi tattoo that killed him, and besides, a tattoo is not a "slip of the tongue."

We actually have a piece coming up soon, maybe this week, maybe next, about the 10 stupidest things politicians said in 2026. But if readers have examples from other elections, we'll be happy to run some of them tomorrow. Send them to comments@electoral-vote.com.


 

D.R. in Thousand Oaks, CA, asks: Rich Lowry just published an item in The New York Post headlined "The Senate filibuster hangs by a thread--and its loss will shatter the Founders' system."

Is Rich Lowry being disingenuous here, or purposely falsifying the facts? Based on my rudimentary knowledge of the Founders' system, it created a Senate, with appointed members rather than elected, and with no mention whatsoever of the need for anything beyond a majority to pass legislation from that body. Yes, the intent of the Senate was to moderate legislation, but surely one cannot reasonably argue that the filibuster makes the institution more democratic, or is what the Founders intended.

Can the resident historian help me out here? Did the Founders intend to impose something other than majority rule, or is my understanding of the situation incorrect?

(Z) answers: "Rich Lowry" is basically a synonym for "disingenuous." So, for that matter, is "The New York Post." Lowry's most recent non-fiction book was savaged by reviewers. For example, one of them wrote "few of Lowry's statements would pass muster with historians" and that his assertions "should be an embarrassment [to] any serious thinker."

The Founders were well aware of the filibuster, though it didn't have that name until after they were all dead. Indeed, in the very first meeting of the U.S. Senate, a bunch of Virginians gave long-winded speeches deliberately meant to derail legislation that was under consideration.

However, that was the speaking filibuster. And a speaking filibuster invariably does have an endpoint, since the member eventually has to eat, or relieve themselves or sleep. The modern filibuster, where it can stretch on without end, did not emerge until nearly 200 years after the Founders exited the scene. If they actually wanted to make it vastly more difficult to advance legislation, they could have put that in the Constitution. After all, they did specify higher vote requirements for: (1) vetoes and (2) impeachments. But they did not include any sort of higher vote requirements for regular order.

So, if Lowry wants to argue the speaking filibuster should come back, allowing the minority to create some hassle on occasions where they really mean it, then there's basis for that. Anything else is, well, disingenuous.


 

P.R. in Arvada, CO, asks: As you were learning about the Civil War, what was the most surprising/impressive thing you learned, what was the best nugget of information you learned that you could drop into a conversation, and what was the thing you learned that made you go "No way can that be true" but is?

(Z) answers: As to your first question, this probably isn't exciting to anyone who is not a historian of the Civil War, I suppose. But Eric Foner's book Free Soil, Free Labor, Free Men: The Ideology of the Republican Party before the Civil War was eye-opening, because it made clear how a majority of Northerners could be anti-slavery without being anti-slavery in the way that modern Americans would be anti-slavery (the main concern for the majority of anti-slavery folks was the economic harm wrought upon the country by slavery, not the morality of the institution).

And the classic nugget of information that delights students and non-students alike is that the first major battle of the Civil War (First Bull Run) was fought substantially on the farm of a man named Wilmer McLean. The farm was wrecked, and McLean decided to move so that the war would not bother him and his family again. He moved to... Appomattox Court House, and his house ended up being used for the surrender of Robert E. Lee and the Army of Northern Virginia. The people present wanted souvenirs, so much of the interior of McLean's house was ruined. In short, the Civil War effectively started and ended at the same guy's house, and the property got wrecked both times.

Since so many people know that one, I'll add another that is somewhat less famous. Because they understood painkillers at the time, but did not particularly understand addiction, one in four Civil War soldiers was a morphine addict by 1880. In an effort to solve the problem, a fellow in Atlanta named John S. Pemberton developed a product meant to help wean them off the opioids. The active ingredient in this product was cocaine—again, they didn't really grasp addiction back then. Obviously, it didn't work. Still, the product went on to be a great success. It was, of course, Coca-Cola.

As to "hard to believe it's true," there are a whole bunch of "it was a smaller world back then" Civil War stories. Perhaps the best known took place when First Son Robert Todd Lincoln, then a civilian, was traveling via train late at night in New Jersey. He was changing trains, stumbled, and fell off the platform into the path of an oncoming train. He was lifted up and rescued at the last moment by... Edwin Booth, brother of John Wilkes Booth. Edwin was a devoted Unionist, while John was a white supremacist and secessionist, and would, of course, go on to assassinate Robert's father (about 2 years later).

And if you want a more substantive "hard to believe it's true," then how about this: About twice as many soldiers in the Civil War died from disease than from enemy bullets. That is true even if you count soldiers who died of infected battle wounds as combat casualties. World War II was actually the first major American war where bullets killed more soldiers than did germs.


 

L.B. in Bozeman, MT, asks: What's a notable or interesting historical event that would make a good movie but that hasn't been made yet?

(Z) answers: I am going to give a Civil War answer. There have been many movies made about the Battle of Gettysburg. There has not been a movie (beyond documentaries) made about the Battle of Shiloh or the Battle of Antietam, which both took place in 1862. The former is quite dramatic, as the Union snatched victory from the jaws of defeat. Plus, the main characters would be Ulysses S. Grant and William T. Sherman, which would be juicy roles. The latter is quite momentous, and it would work well to set Abraham Lincoln up as the main protagonist, Frederick Douglass as the deuteragonist and George McClellan as the antagonist.


 

F.S. in Cologne, Germany, asks: Who are the 10 most influential non-American filmmakers?

(Z) answers: I'm not going to attempt a ranking, because the places, the eras and the types of impact are so difficult to compare. So, this will just be in alphabetical order. Also, I am going to count a person based on where they spent their formative years, not where they worked as an adult. So, for example, Stanley Kubrick can't be on the list because he was American, even if he spent most of his working years in the U.K.

And with that:

  1. Chantal Akerman: Jeanne Dielman, 23 quai du Commerce, 1080 Bruxelles was not really my cup of tea. But the experts say it opened filmmakers' eyes to: (1) feminist themes, and (2) focusing on the tedium of everyday life, as opposed to just that which is extraordinary. That film was also the first woman-directed film to top the every-10-years Sight & Sound poll of the greatest films ever made.

  2. Pedro Almodóvar: Somewhat similar story to Akerman, except that instead of feminist themes, it's LGBTQ themes.

  3. Ingmar Bergman: There are musicians that had much more impact on other musicians than on the general public. The same is true of filmmakers, and Bergman is one of those. He did more than 60 films and documentaries, and while they were not huge commercial successes, and mostly are not well known in the United States, they were huge on the art-house circuit, and had a profound effect on how other filmmakers made war movies, thrillers, character studies, historical dramas and fantasy films.

  4. Charlie Chaplin: This might be the most obvious inclusion on the list. As one of a trio of dominant comic filmmakers working during and immediately after the birth of the medium (along with Buster Keaton and Harold Lloyd), he helped create the visual language of filmmaking, and produced a string of smash hits that reached audiences on both sides of the Atlantic.

  5. Federico Fellini: His visual approach influenced generations of filmmakers. And while his originals don't show up too much in modern-day cinemas, his films have been frequently the basis for thinly veiled remakes (e.g., Pee Wee's Big Adventure and Lost in Translation are both takes on La Dolce Vita).

  6. Alfred Hitchcock: The other candidate for the most obvious inclusion on the list. He was an active and important filmmaker for four decades, both in movies and TV, and he is more responsible than anyone for creating the modern thriller. There also might not be a filmmaker who is more frequently referenced in other artists' films; the early Pixar films, for example, are practically a catalogue of Hitchcock bits.

  7. Akira Kurosawa: The most important Japanese director of all time, and another whose visual style influenced generations. Like Fellini, a lot of his films were remade for American audiences. Most obviously, The Seven Samurai became The Magnificent Seven, while the concept behind Rashomon (showing different characters' version of the same events) has been the basis for hundreds of films and TV episodes.

  8. Hayao Miyazaki: We are currently in a new Golden Age of Animation, and no foreign-born filmmaker has done more to make that possible than Miyazaki, who co-founded Studio Ghibli, and directed the influential My Neighbor Totoro, Princess Mononoke and Spirited Away, among others.

  9. Christopher Nolan: I can't know the future, but at the moment, Nolan is clearly the most important filmmaker of his generation, something of a Spielberg v2.0.

  10. Jean Renoir: La Grande Illusion and The Rules of the Game both regularly appear in the Top 10 of the Sight & Sound poll, despite the fact that their 100th birthdays are not far off. Orson Welles called him "the greatest of all directors" and a great many other filmmakers have cited him as a major influence, among them Robert Altman, Martin Scorsese and Peter Bogdanovich.

I have a list of runners-up. However, I am sure readers will want to weigh in, at comments@electoral-vote.com, ideally with one or two names, and a brief comment as to why that person should be on the list. We will run some of those responses tomorrow, along with my list of runners-up.


 

Y.H. in Toronto, ON, Canada, asks: Is Elon Musk as close to a real-life personification of a Bond villain as we've seen in many, many years, probably several decades? And which would you say he's closest to?

I say Max Zorin. A tech guy with celebrity-level public persona, enormous wealth, a massive business empire and a desire to reshape entire industries (plural).

(Z) answers: Musk is certainly the most Bond-like villain we've seen recently, though I don't know about several decades. Martin Shkreli is pretty Bond-villain-like. Maybe Elizabeth Holmes, too.

And I think the closest fit is Hugo Drax. They are both people who built their fortunes in industry, and then turned their eyes toward conquering space. It is true, I will concede, that Drax actually plans a genocide, whereas Musk merely indulges in the kind of rhetoric that sometimes leads genocide.


 

E.W. in Skaneateles, NY, asks: In the Lord of the Rings legendarium, the palantir were seeing stones that corrupted the user. Why then would Peter Thiel, et al. name their software company this? I get being a Tolkien fan but it seems like that name is cursed.

(Z) answers: Presumably, they are focused on the part of the book(s) where, in the right hands (e.g., Aragorn), the palantir is a force of good, and conveys great power and insight.

I suppose they did not read most of the rest of the books. You know, where everyone thinks they can control the One Ring, and harness its positive qualities, but in fact cannot?


 

J.A. in Kansas City, MO, asks: Thanks for answering the question from F.S. in Cologne about your favorite anti-heroes. Just wondering if you considered Rick Blaine for inclusion in your list?

(Z) answers: I did. But since Humphrey Bogart had already made the list once (Sam Spade), I decided that spot was better used for a different entry.


 

L.H. in Chicago, IL, asks: On Saturday's question about anti-heroes, you wrote this about Tom Joad from The Grapes of Wrath: "But don't forget, he's also a convicted murderer, and one who has to leave the family after committing a second killing."

I read the book twice—once in high school in the 70s and again about a decade ago, and if memory serves, Tom's original conviction seemed like a miscarriage of justice. If I recall the details correctly, he was in a knife fight and the other guy actually had a knife inside of Tom. Even as a high school student, it seemed to me that Tom's conviction only came about because he was poor white trash. Anyone with a lawyer could have pled self-defense.

While I don't recall as well the details of the later killing, my sense was that it was also a kind of self-defense, albeit in a more metaphorical sense—that the one he had no choice but to kill was a threat to his family in a way that the corrupt justice system would provide no protection from. The 1930s equivalent of running over an ICE agent who was in the process of shooting at you.

The point is not to deny that Tom is responsible for killing, but under the particular circumstances, don't you think that those killings require a more nuanced judgment of Tom's character than simply "murderer"?

(Z) answers: For the first killing, which is punished as a homicide, we have only Tom's word that he was defending himself. Meanwhile, the second killing came when a hired security guard killed Tom's friend Casy in cold blood, and Tom grabbed the guard's club and avenged the killing. Would that be considered justifiable in a court of law, since Tom himself was not attacked and was not (apparently) in danger, and was already a convicted felon? Hard to say.

In any event, John Steinbeck was working in California at the same time that folks like Raymond Chandler and Dashiell Hammett were creating fiction noir. And one of the things that fiction noir made clear is that your antagonist, even if he or she is basically heroic, does not need to be squeaky-clean and perfect like Superman. Steinbeck's clear intent was to create a non-traditional hero—working class, put upon, spotty track record, world-weary, sometimes morally ambiguous. In other words, an anti-hero.


 

R.C. in Des Moines, IA, asks: The first two anti heroes who popped into my mind were Snake Plissken and Mad Max. I loved your list, but... Ellen Ripley?

(Z) answers: As I note in the previous answer, an anti-hero is one who has qualities not traditionally indicative of a hero. Ripley is pretty raggedy. She has an established history of rule-breaking. She doesn't particularly want to serve in her current post, and is just trying to get home. Oh, and in the context in which that movie came out (Alien was released in 1979), Ripley was lacking something else that virtually all traditional heroes had, namely... a penis. Perhaps if that movie was released this year, the case for Ripley as anti-hero would not be as strong. But nearly 50 years ago? She certainly was not a "traditional" hero.


 

I.S. in Cap Ferret, France, asks: For decades, social conservatives across the West, but particularly in the U.S., have tried to draw a link between crime and violent music, video games, and films. They are doing it again, this time with the release of Grand Theft Auto VI. I have been playing the GTA series and Mass Effect since I was 12 and never had the desire to shoot machine guns into schools or drive cars into crowds of people.

I think years of research should show this allegation is false. Statistics have shown crime has fallen in the U.S. over the past 35 years, except during the pandemic. The U.S. is a much safer place than it was in the 1980s.

Why do people keep pushing this stuff and isn't the field of criminology debunking this propaganda?

(Z) answers: This is really not a criminology question, it's more for sociologists and psychologists.

Anyhow, I once worked for a professor at UCLA who did research on sexual violence. And the conclusion, over and over, was that sexually violent films have no impact on most people, serve as a "release" for some small percentage who might otherwise act out on their predilections, and serve as "encouragement" for a different small percentage.

The net effect, since the violent stuff is forestalling some acts, and encouraging others, is very, very small. Further, we live in a society where we have accepted, in many ways, that there will have to be some bad stuff in order for there to be considerably more good stuff. To take one small example, there would be far fewer freeway fatalities if the speed limit was 20 MPH. But the additional lives saved are not worth the much greater amount of travel time, in the judgment of society.

In short, while my knowledge is specifically about sexual violence, I think it probably extends to non-sexual violence, and that you have the right of it: This is much ado about nothing (or next to nothing). As to the people who gnash their teeth and rend their garments, some of that is media outlets looking to get a rise (and clicks) out of readers, some of it is the "get off my lawn" crowd who see the game as a symbol of everything that's gone wrong with society since they were kids, and some of it is the culture-wars folks looking for their latest battle.


 

R.H.D. in Webster, NY, asks: At the beginning of this college football season, I asked if the Big Ten could make it four years in a row of winning the national championship. Now that we are closing in on the playoffs, do you still think anyone from there can make it? Right now, it looks like only Indiana or UCLA have a real shot.

(Z) answers: I have watched all the UCLA games, and while they are a heck of a story and have a stellar defense, they've also played a fairly soft schedule. I am not persuaded they can win multiple games in a row against teams like Georgia and Miami. Meanwhile, Indiana is clearly a weaker team than last year, which will happen when you lose your Heisman-trophy-winning starting QB.

In other words, I do not think either of these teams is a legitimate national title contender (though, of course, I would be pleased to have UCLA prove me wrong). Meanwhile, it looks like the SEC will probably get four teams into the playoff. So, the smart money says this is the SEC's year.


 

N.S. in Lafayette, CO, asks: Of their two remaining opponents in the regular season, who is more likely to beat UCLA? "Nobody" does not answer the question... I said "more likely." (Note: time-critical question, you gotta answer before the Michigan game).

(Z) answers: USC is the much more challenging opponent, especially since they are probably going to be playing for their coach's job. Indiana, likely to be UCLA's opponent in the Big Ten title game, is tougher than either USC or Michigan, but you specified "regular season."


 

E.S. in Providence, RI, asks: Does your crystal ball tell you that there will be a 2027 baseball season, or that the owners will lock out the players over the CBA negotiations? If the latter, how long do you predict it will last, and what do you foresee as the outcome?

(Z) answers: There is going to be a lockout. That is basically beyond doubt.

The question is exactly how willing the two sides are to go nuclear. The owners are posturing right now, and are saying they will not move forward without a salary cap. The players are also posturing, and are saying they will not accept a cap, and if they have to, they might just dissolve the union and then go to court and challenge the owners' anti-trust exemption.

If both are serious, then the season is probably done for. However, if you made me bet, I would bet that spring training and a chunk of the regular season are lost, and then they end up with a deal that's not exactly a salary cap, but is also not exactly NOT a salary cap (like, say, an even more punitive luxury tax).


 

F.D. in St. Paul, MN, asks: Now that my childhood favorite Milwaukee Brewers broke my 44-year waiting period to return to the (and win their first!) World Series, I have a much less consequential question: what is the best logo in MLB/all U.S. sports?

The return of the Brewers "ball and glove" logo was a great moment, as was the "TC" logo in Minnesota, but my all time favorite is the Expos logo (RIP)—it covered all the bases.

(Z) answers: I think the greatest logo in the four major North American sports is the logo of the Los Angeles Lakers:

Logo of the Los Angeles Lakers, which features
a basketball, and the word Lakers rendered in a font that includes streaks like blowing wind

It's one of the most iconic sports logos in the world, and it conveys better than any other the basic culture of the team. The "wind" coming off the team name says, "We're fast-paced, razzle-dazzle." And that is exactly the Lakers' identity. After all, they were long known as "Showtime" (though the current joke, given that their three best players are white, is that the team is now "Snowtime").

The best baseball logo is that of the New York Yankees. I don't care for the Evil Empire, but it's very old-school, and yet meshes perfectly with their pinstriped uniforms:

An interlocking N and Y in an
old-timey script font

Fun fact: That logo was created by the famous designer Louis C. Tiffany. He did not design it for the Yankees, mind you, he designed it for a medal that was being given out by the city of New York. The Yankees just "borrowed" it.


 

M.S. in Highland Park, IL, asks: Can you comment on Disney adults and the cultural atmosphere giving rise to them? I maintain that being a Disney adult is no different from being a Chicago Bears fan, as both involve dressing in expensive merchandise and planning weekends/vacations around corporate entertainment. My husband (a Chicago Bears fan) disagrees.

(Z) answers: I don't think adult Disney fandom is that similar to adult sports fandom, except for the handful of people where that becomes their basic identity ("Oh, he's the Disney superfan;" "Oh, she's the Bears superfan").

In terms of actual parallels to Disney adult fandom, the activity that I first thought of—where people read lots of websites, and dress up in costumes, and go out of their house to commune with like-minded people—was MAGA people and their rallies and other events. In both cases, it is at least partly a reaction to the many negative things about modern life, and a desire to go back to a time when things were a little simpler. Of course, the MAGA folks are much more harmful than the Disney folks, but I would say the dynamic is somewhat similar.


 

T.J.R. in Metuchen, NJ, asks: What do you think of Christmas Albums by Jewish artists? Notably, Barbra Streisand, Neil Diamond, Bob Dylan, Barry Manilow, etc.

Of course, I'm not denying those (or any other non-Christian) artists from recording Christmas songs. They have as much right as do so as anyone else. And there are universal and/or secular sentiments expressed in many of the songs.

I just find it... disconcerting... as I feel the impetus is by-and-large commercial.

(Z) answers: I find nothing objectionable, concerning, or disconcerting here.

First, as you note, the ideas in many of the songs are also found in other religions. Particularly Judaism, since it's also an Abrahamic religion. Second, as you also note, Christmas is a secular holiday, almost certainly more so than it is a religious one these days.

Perhaps most importantly, a good song is a good song. Hundreds of artists have covered "Hallelujah," by Leonard Cohen. While that's not exactly a Christmas song, it could be. And I am certain that not all of those artists were Jewish (as Cohen was), or were practicing Christians. It's just a good song.

There's also a pretty long list of examples of Jewish artists engaging with Christian themes. For example, the most Jesus-y song of the hippie years is surely "Spirit in the Sky," written by the Jewish Norman Greenbaum. Similarly, the show Little House on the Prairie was rife with Christian themes, despite the fact that star, producer and lead writer Michael Landon was Jewish. I presume that Greenbaum and Landon felt the spirit of the art was the most important thing.

Now, if you want to lament that nearly all produced music is commercialized, that I can see. But I am no more bothered by Bob Dylan (who, by the way, has spent a fair chunk of his life as a born-again Christian) or Barbra Streisand recording a Christmas album than I am Eric Clapton or Nirvana covering a blues song.


 

K.H. in Albuquerque, NM, asks: You raised the subject of board games, and I'll certainly be giving Sea Salt and Paper a go. It's timely, because our local Botanic Garden is having an Origami in the Garden exhibition from this October through March.

One board-game issue that I frequently run into is that with three players, one person gains an advantage and then it's just a matter of who can lose the slowest for the other two.

That said, my two buddies who gather for game night every now and then have been stuck on Carcassone for quite a while. While I agree that standard Risk is weak, we discovered that Star Wars Risk (original trilogy) is a very acceptable 3-player game. Even when all seems lost, there can be surprising twists at the last moment.

Do you have any other suggestions for 3-player board games?

(A) answers: Some people use "board games" to describe any game using a board and/or cards and/or dice, etc. Increasingly, the term "tabletop game" has come into use, to describe any game played on a table, whether a board is involved or not. Thus, all board games are tabletop games, but not all tabletop games are board games. Most of the games that come to mind for your request are tabletop games, but not board games. Let us know if you're specifically looking for board games, and we can dig more into that subgenre. And with that caveat:

Board Games

Ticket to Ride: You never really know how well other players are doing until tickets are tallied up at the end. I've only played on the U.S. and Europe maps. Of those two, I prefer Europe, where the major destinations are distributed more evenly.

Tabletop Games

Colt Express: Players are aware of some of each other's moves, but some are made in secret. Will your brilliant strategy still be brilliant after your opponents make their moves?

River Valley Glassworks: There are layers of strategies in this deceptively simple game of collecting glass.

Tiny Laser Heist: This is a dexterity game; not what most people think of when they're looking for a board/tabletop game. But every round potentially has a different team-up, so it might be perfect for your needs.


 

A.B. in Wendell, NC, asks: Now that Staff Dachshunds Emeritus Otto and Flash have gone on to Rainbow Bridge, and Staff Canine Tuco is filling their previous role, will Tuco be getting a sibling anytime soon, or will we, going forward, have a solitary Staff Canine? Of course, being a dog lover myself, I know we never have them... they have us!! I am proud to be owned by a Husky/Norwegian Elkhound mix named Neka.

(Z) answers: Probably so. He's a high-energy pup, and could really use a companion to help burn some of that energy. However, the dog rescues are tough to work with, and time is needed to acclimate a new arrival. For these reasons, I probably won't get serious about the matter until I can be home most of the time (i.e., summer break).


 

B.J.L. in Ann Arbor, MI, asks: I'm drowning in grading this term. Given the reduction in staff support at the university level, I am left on my own to cover a class of 40-ish students and with all of the other job requirements (proposals, funding, and a small admin appointment), I just handed out my second exam and have two homeworks and a project sitting in the queue for grading. I just decided moments ago to abandon grading the homeworks, giving them all full credit for these and grading the exam instead. Have you guys run into similar things, or are you having Claude just wrap it up, given the students probably used it to complete the assignment?

(Z) answers: (V) is emeritus, but I certainly have the same problem, which is why the blog might be late/canceled a few times in the next month. That said, the day I let Claude or any other AI program do any of my teaching or grading for me is the day I retire.


 

J.M. in Portland, OR, asks: I don't play the headline game but I always scan through the list of winners to see where they are all from. Can you easily tell me if there is a state in the union where you have never gotten a winner?

(Z) answers: We have not had a successful submission from North Dakota, as far as we can tell.


 

K.C. in West Islip, NY, asks: Saturday's posting was late due to rain and power outages. Are you saying that it actually does rain in southern California?

(Z) answers: I almost wrote that Albert Hammond Sr. lied to me, but then I thought not many people would get the joke.



This item appeared on www.electoral-vote.com. Read it Monday through Friday for political and election news, Saturday for answers to reader's questions, and Sunday for letters from readers.

www.electoral-vote.com                     State polls                     All Senate candidates