Dem 55
image description
Ties 1
GOP 44
image description

Kirsten Gillibrand's Lucky Number is 60

It looks like Mary Peltola will win the Alaska Senate race, giving the Democrats 56 Senate seats. Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY) has signed up for a second term as chair of the DSCC. She is dreaming of getting 60 Democratic senators—which is enough to invoke cloture and stop a filibuster—without having to slay the beast. We had an item last week looking at the 2028 Senate from a defensive standpoint for the Democrats, namely: Could they lose control of the Senate then? Gillibrand is looking at the 2028 Senate from an offense point of view. Could the Democrats actually get to 60?

Here is her reasoning. First, it is a generally favorable map for the Democrats, with not many vulnerable Democrats up. Sen. John Fetterman (D?-PA) is up, but he has already drawn two primary challengers and there probably will be more. We cannot conceive of Gillibrand spending any money to bail out Fetterman—assuming he even runs, which he might not. Most of the Democrats up are in blue states (see list in page linked to above). The only one in a red state is Sen. Sherrod Brown (D-OH), and he just won against an incumbent. In 2028, he will be the incumbent. Only two Democrats in swing states are up: Sen. Maggie Hassan (D-NH) and Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto (D-NV). New Hampshire is a bluish-purple state and Sen.-elect Chris Pappas (D) just beat a strong opponent, former senator John Sununu (R), by 14 points, so Hassan is probably safe (certainly if the Democrat is elected president). In 2026, Latinos swung heavily toward the Democrats. If they do again in 2028, Cortez Masto, who is a Latina herself, is safe.

So in a reasonably good year, Democrats won't lose any Senate seats. Where does Gillibrand think she can pick up four more seats? The lowest hanging fruit is in Wisconsin, where Sen. Ron Johnson (R-WI) is up, and North Carolina, where Sen. Ted Budd (R-NC) is up. Democrats did very well in both states last week, especially North Carolina, where Roy Cooper (D) won by 20 points. Winning those two would get the Democrats to 58 seats.

In Iowa. Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-IA) is up. He will be 95 in 2028 and might finally decide that he is not up to doing the full Grassley (campaigning in all of Iowa's 100 counties) anymore. That would mean an open seat. Sen.-elect Josh Turek (D) just won an open seat in Iowa by 5 points. Could another Democrat do that in 2028? It is certainly conceivable. That would get the Democrats to 59.

Where would they get the 60th seat? Sen. Jerry Moran (R-KS) is up in Kansas. Sen.-elect Adam Hamilton (D), pastor of the biggest church in Kansas, won his state last week, although his opponent, Sen. Roger Marshall (R-KS), was deeply flawed. Could the Democrats find the pastor of the second-biggest church and get him to run as a Democrat using Hamilton's playbook?

Gillibrand also noted that the Democrats won a Senate seat in South Carolina last week, albeit against a weak candidate who was parachuted into the race without benefit of a primary. Sen. Tim Scott (R-SC) is up next time there. He's more popular than Lindsey Graham was, and certainly more popular than Darline Graham. So, this one strikes us as a reach. That said, we didn't expect Sen.-elect Annie Andrews (D) to win either.

Gillibrand hasn't named any other targets, but last week, Sen.-elect Julia Letlow (R) won by only 1.8 points in Louisiana. Sen. John Kennedy (R-LA) is up in 2028. About 33% of Louisiana voters are Black, more than South Carolina (26%) but less than Mississippi (38%). It could be worth a shot, and Louisiana is a cheap state to advertise in. Louisiana or South Carolina could be that 60th seat.

And there is one other—very outside—possibility. Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-AK) is up in 2028. She has a lot of problems with the current iteration of the Republican Party. It is conceivable that Gillibrand could have a woman-to-woman talk with Murkowski and say to her: "You can't stand your own party. Why don't you become an independent and caucus with us, like Angus [King, I-ME]?" With half the pigs in Iowa thrown in, Murkowski might take the deal. Donald Trump could threaten to primary her if she did this before the election, but due to Alaska's top-four ranked-choice general election, Murkowski wouldn't have to worry about not being on the November ballot. And the Democrats could field someone who (quietly) promised to drop out after making the general-election ballot, making it Murkowski, the Republican nominee, and whoever came in next. After the other candidate was eliminated, it would be Murkowski vs. the Republican, with all the Democrats and some of the Republicans backing the senator.

Is 60 seats just Gillibrand's fever dream? Two years is forever in politics, but there is a path for it. Needless to say, being able to invoke cloture all the time without having to change the Senate rules would be a godsend to the Democrats. (V)



This item appeared on www.electoral-vote.com. Read it Monday through Friday for political and election news, Saturday for answers to reader's questions, and Sunday for letters from readers.

www.electoral-vote.com                     State polls                     All Senate candidates