Dem 56
image description
   
GOP 44
image description

...Even in the State Supreme Court Elections

The blue wave went deep. We already had an item on how the Democrats went from 24 governorships to 30 governorships, which now cover 75% of the population. We also had an item on how the Democrats swept statewide offices across the country and also flipped 12 state legislatures to get a trifecta in 22 states. Additionally, we had an item on how well the Democrats did in elections for secretaries of state—you know, the folks who run elections in most states, not all of whom may have enough backbone to resist "finding" 11,780 new votes when the president demands that.

But there is still more. In many states, justices for the state Supreme Court are elected, either in an out-and-out partisan election with (D) and (R) labels, or in a barely hidden partisan election without the labels, but where everyone knows who is on which team. It is an interesting concept. Many people are talking about Supreme Court reform, by which they mean things like enforceable ethical standards about bribes gifts and exotic vacations and term limits. Why not go whole hog and have the U.S. Supreme Court justices be elected in (almost) openly partisan elections, like in many states? After all, everything they do is partisan anyway, so why not let the voters decide which party they want in control? The states are the laboratories for democracy and all that. They already do it and could lead the way here.

That said, the blue wave did reach down (up?) to Supreme Court elections as well on Nov. 3. These are important because many issues, from abortion laws to election laws, end up in state Supreme Courts. Twenty-three states held elections for 42 state Supreme Court seats on Nov 3, in addition to the eight states that had Supreme Court elections earlier this year. Some were retention elections, when a (possibly appointed) justice had to face the voters in a straight up retain-or-fire election, and some regular (partisan) multicandidate elections.

Texas was the biggest surprise, with Democrats flipping all four seats on the state Supreme Court that were on the ballot to go from 0D, 9R to a new Court with 4D, 5R. No Democrat had won a seat there in over 30 years. The chief justice, Jimmy Blacklock, was defeated by a woman, Maggie Ellis, who will now become the first female chief justice in Texas history. The Court's conservatism may be moderated now that the other justices—especially the three Republican justices up in 2028—feel which way the wind is blowing. The Supreme Court handles civil cases. Criminal cases are handled by the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals. There, Democrats flipped three seats to get to a 3D, 6R Court. Three more Republican seats are up in 2028. This means the Democrats have a shot at getting majorities in both Courts in 2028.

In Ohio, prior to the 2022, Supreme Court justices were (nominally) nonpartisan—at least, there were no (D) or (R) labels on the actual ballots. Then the Republican-controlled legislature decided to label each candidate with his or her party on the ballot, thinking that would help Republicans. Uh, No. Democrats flipped one Supreme Court seat, leading to a 2D, 5R Court next year. Two of the Republican justices are up in 2028, meaning that Democratic wins in both would give the Democrats a majority. A perpetual hot issue in Ohio is gerrymandering and flipping the Court could definitely change rulings on that touchy subject.

In some cases, Democrats didn't pick up new seats, but held their own. In North Carolina, Anita Earls (D), a former civil rights lawyer, beat Sarah Stevens (R), a former Republican state House member, to get a second term. Over $8 million was spent in that race, the most expense Supreme Court election this year. In 2028, three of the Republicans will be up. If Democrats win two of those elections, they will control the Court 4D, 3R. If they sweep all three, their majority will be 5D, 2R.

In Montana, where Supreme Court elections are nominally nonpartisan, not-very-well-hidden Democrat Amy Eddy beat not-very-well-hidden Republican Dan Wilson. The Montana Court doesn't always fit into partisan categories, as the justices try to reach consensus when they can. Still, Eddy is a voice for the more liberal position. In 2028, two of the more liberal justices are up, so conservatives have a chance to take control. A ballot measure 2 week ago that enshrined nonpartisanship for Supreme Court elections in the state Constitution won overwhelmingly.

No state Supreme Courts flipped this year, but the elections set up possible flips to the Democrats in 2028 in Texas, Ohio, and North Carolina, three large states. If you are looking for a discussion of the final results in every Supreme Court election on Nov. 3, here is a good one. (V)



This item appeared on www.electoral-vote.com. Read it Monday through Friday for political and election news, Saturday for answers to reader's questions, and Sunday for letters from readers.

www.electoral-vote.com                     State polls                     All Senate candidates