News from the Votemaster
To the great relief of the Republican establishment, Sen. Thad Cochran (R-MS) defeated tea party challenger Chris McDaniel 51% to 49% in the Republican senatorial runoff yesterday. However, instead of gracefully conceding, McDaniel gave a fiery speech last night promising to challenge the results. Traditionally, the courts are very hesitant to overrule the voters, but it's not over until the fat lady sings, especially if she is a judge.
This has been one of the meanest and most bitter primaries in years. Cochran is an old-school Southern politician, conservative, but polite and courtly to everyone, even to Democrats, with whom he often works on order to get lots of federal money for his poor state. His entire campaign has been based on the premise that he can do more for Mississippi than McDaniel. In contrast, McDaniel's campaign has been about reducing the size and influence of the federal government, and if that means less money for Mississippi, so be it.
In the primary election three weeks ago, McDaniel edged Cochran by 0.8% of the vote, but neither candidate cleared 50%, thus forcing yesterday's runoff. About $17 million was spent on the runoff, virtually all of it coming from out of state. Both establishment groups and tea party groups poured money into the state.
Turnout was much higher yesterday than in the primary itself, which is very unusual. Cochran made a huge pitch to black Democrats to vote for him in the runoff and it worked. Turnout was especially high in areas with large black populations and it favored Cochran heavily. In the 24 counties with a black majority, turnout was up 40%, compared to 16% statewide. This will be the basis of any McDaniel legal challenge. Under Mississippi law, to vote in a partisan primary, a voter has to promise to support his or her party's nominee in the general election. Thus any Democrat who voted yesterday for Cochran and who plans to vote for the Democrat, Travis Childers, in November, broke the law. However, since the November election is by secret ballot, it will be impossible to prosecute anyone. People who voted in the June 3 Democratic primary could, in principle, be prosecuted, but even that is doubtful since a voter could say: "My candidate lost in the Democratic primary and I don't like the winner, so I am voting Republican in the Fall." If McDaniel goes to court, he will claim that Cochran's win was based on thousands of people breaking the law by voting when technically they were not eligible. But proving that some voter was not eligible because he or she plans to vote for the Democrat in the general election will be a tough sell. Statistically, there is no doubt that McDaniel is right, but getting a judge to throw out an election on the grounds that probably a lot of ineligible voters voted will be a tough sell.
Whether it was wise for black Democrats to vote for an elderly conservative Republican is certainly arguable. On the one hand, he will bring home more pork, bacon, and other pig products than McDaniel would have, especially since McDaniel would have no seniority and is against the idea in principle. So Cochran's reelection could bring tangible benefits to the state's poorest citizens. On the other hand, A McDaniel victory would have put the state in play and made it much harder for the Republicans to capture the Senate. A Republican Senate will probably not look kindly on spending federal money to help poor black people. So was it wise for poor black Democrats to vote for Cochran instead of McDaniel? The voters thought so, even if political strategists might have thought otherwise.
For a while this year, the narrative has been: "The establishment strikes back." Then after McDaniel's narrow win in the primary and Eric Cantor's defeat at the hands of an unknown tea party candidate in Virginia, it changed to: "the tea party is alive and kicking." Now it will be: "Maybe the tea party can't win after all." It has been an unusual year so far.
In more good news for the Republicans, former congressman Bob Beauprez won a four-way primary for the right to challenge Gov. John Hickenlooper (D-CO) for the governorship of Colorado in November. While that race does not have national implications, one of the candidates Beauprez beat was former congressman Tom Tancredo, a fiery opponent of immigration reform. Had Tancredo won, immigration would have become a major issue in the general election and this would have ginned up Latino turnout. In turn, this would have helped Sen. Mark Udall (D-CO), who is running for reelection against Rep. Cory Gardner (R-CO). With Beauprez on the Republican ticket instead of Tancredo, Udall will not get a big lift from a nasty discussion about immigration.Email a link to a friend or share:
Jun04 Independent Gums Up the Works in Mississippi
Jun04 Joni Ernst to Face Bruce Braley in Iowa
Jun04 Independent Gums Up the Works in Mississippi
May28 Democrats Escape Disaster in Texas
May28 Republicans Court Disaster in Texas
May21 Perdue and Kingston Advance to Runoff in Georgia Senate Race
May21 McConnell Whips Bevin in Kentucky
May21 Wehby Beats Conger in Oregon
May21 Chelsea Clinton's Mother-in-law Loses in Pennsylvania
May18 How Republican is the South?
May07 Tillis Wins North Carolina Primary
May07 Boehner Renominated Easily
May07 Long View of the Senate
May07 Future Voters May Use iPads
Apr23 Summary of the Prognosticators on the 2014 Senate Races
Apr23 North Carolina Primary is Next
Apr23 Other Southern Races Tight
Apr07 Scott Brown Makes Freudian Slip
Apr07 Republican Poll Shows Landrieu Ahead in Louisiana
Mar24 Methodology Matters
Mar24 Rand Paul May Have to Make a Choice in 2016
Mar11 Version 1.0 of the 2016 Republican Presidential Primaries
Mar11 Tier 1 Candidates
Mar11 Tier 2 Candidates
Mar11 Tier 3 Candidates
Mar11 Hotly Contested Special Election in Florida Today to Fill GOP House Seat
Mar05 Cornyn Renominated in Texas
Mar03 Ohio Eliminates Early Voting on Sundays
Mar03 Travis Childers to Run for the Senate in Mississippi
Feb26 Primary Season Begins Next Week
Feb08 Lt. Gov. John Walsh Appointed to Replace Baucus in the Senate
Feb03 Christie and 2016
Feb03 Update on the Key 2014 Senate Races
Dec19 Obama Names Max Baucus as Ambassador to China
Dec19 Democrats Sweep Virginia Statewide Offices
Nov23 The Senate Did Not Really Abolish the Filibuster
Nov06 Virginia is for Democrats
Nov06 Christie Wins Big in New Jersey
Nov06 The Establishment Strikes Back
Nov06 De Blasio Crushes Lhota in New York City
Nov06 Many Referendums on the Ballot
Nov05 All Eyes on Virginia and New Jersey
Nov05 Business Fights Back: Key Republican Primary to Be Held in Alabama Today
Nov05 Liberals Poised for Big Wins in New York City
Nov05 Key Ballot Measures Will Also Get Attention
Nov05 Bass Will Not Challenge Shaheen in New Hampshire
Oct17 Cory Booker Elected Senator from New Jersey
Oct17 Government Crisis Postponed for 3 Months
Oct01 The Blame Game Begins