Obama 332
image description
Romney 206
image description
Dem 55
image description
GOP 45
image description
  • Strongly Dem (191)
  • Likely Dem (72)
  • Barely Dem (69)
  • Exactly tied (0)
  • Barely GOP (15)
  • Likely GOP (16)
  • Strongly GOP (175)
270 Electoral votes needed to win Map algorithm explained
New polls: (None)
Dem pickups: (None)
GOP pickups: IN NC
PW logo Fixing America, Not the World Is Cuomo the Conservative Democrat in 2016?
GOP Rejects Obama Offer on Fiscal Cliff Lawmaker Creates Best Excuse Yet for Ignoring Pledge
Why Isn't Obama Using His Email List? Boehner Claims No Progress on Fiscal Cliff Talks

News from the Votemaster

How Well Did the Pollsters Do?

The time to analyze the state pollsters is now. Here's how we did it. For each pollster that ran at least five state presidential polls released after Oct. 1, each state polled by that pollster was examined separately. For each state-pollster combination, only the last poll was used. That poll was compared to the final result in the state. If, for example, a pollster said Obama was +3 in some state and the final result was Obama +1, the error was recorded as +2 (biased toward Obama). If the election result was Obama +5, then the pollster's score was -2 (biased toward Romney).

For each pollster, its score in each state it polled was averaged and a bias and error score computed. Bias is how much the average across states was skewed toward Obama or Romney. Error is the mean absolute value of how far off the pollster was. For example, a pollster who overrated Obama by 10 points in half the states and who underrated Obama by 10 points in the other half would have a bias of 0. The mean error would be 10, however, since every result was off by 10 points. The pollster was not very accurate, but didn't favor either candidate.

In contrast, a pollster who overrated Obama by 1 point in 5 states and who was spot on in 5 states would have a bias of +0.5 and also a mean error of 0.5. Although this pollster has a slight bias, it is clearly better than the first one, which has no bias but is wildly inaccurate.

Here are the numbers. Remember that negative numbers mean a bias toward Romney and positive numbers mean a bias toward Obama.

Pollster States
Bias Error
U. of New Hampshire 2 -4.5% 4.5%
ARG 7 -4.1% 4.1%
Quinnipiac U. 8 -2.6% 3.4%
Pulse Opinion Research 5 -2.6% 2.6%
Rasmussen 21 -2.4% 3.8%
Mason Dixon 9 -2.4% 5.3%
Marist Coll. 9 -1.3% 2.7%
IPSOS 4 -1.2% 2.2%
PPP 22 -1.2% 3.2%
SurveyUSA 14 -1.1% 2.6%
ORC International 3 -1.0% 1.7%
Angus-Reid 5 +1.2% 5.2%
Pharos Research Group 7 +1.3% 3.0%
Zogby 3 +2.0% 4.0%

Let's go over this to make it clearer. The University of New Hampshire polled only two states after Oct. 1: New Hampshire and Massachusetts. In New Hampshire, it predicted a 3-point Obama win. He won by 6. In Massachusetts, it predicted a 17-point Obama win. He won by 23. So the mean bias is (-3 + -6)/2 = -4.5. The mean error is the average of 3 and 6 or 4.5. Now consider ORC International (used by CNN). It's Colorado, Florida, and Ohio final polls were biased by -2, -2, and +1 respectively, for an average bias of -1.0, a small pro-Romney bias. The mean error, however, is (2 + 2 + 1)/3 = 1.7.

The bottom line is that the least biased pollster was ORC International, which overestimated Romney by 1%. ORC International was also the most accurate pollster, with a mean error of only 1.7%. Good job ORC International. (Note to CNN executives: hire them next time.)

Also noteworthy is that it is hard to find an article about the North Carolina PPP firm that doesn't describe it as "Democratic leaning." Actually, it had a 1.2% bias toward Romney. It overestimated his performance. Rasmussen also had a Republican bias and it was twice as large as PPP's. Only three pollsters, Angus-Reid, Pharos, and Zogby, were biased toward Obama, and then not by very much. The margin of error in most state polls is 3-4%, so a pollster with a mean error below 4% was pretty much on target. Only the University of New Hampshire and ARG fell off the boat.

Finally, all the comments from right-wing pundits that the pollsters were biased toward Obama were nonsense. Of the 14 major pollsters in our study, 11 had a Republican bias. Only three small pollsters had a Democratic bias.

The Season's Almost Over

This is pretty close to the end for 2012. Maybe we'll make up a page with the 2014 Senate races and maybe one on the 2016 candidates, but other than that, we've about covered 2012 now. If you want to see if there has been a posting, the easiest way is to subscribe to the Twitter or RSS feeds. Every posting is announced there. Thanks for visiting. Maybe we'll be back in 2014, maybe not. No promises.

Email a link to a friend or share:

---The Votemaster
Nov22 Happy Thanksgiving
Nov21 Iowa Governor Wants to Kill the Ames Straw Poll
Nov21 Jim Messina Tells How Obama Won
Nov21 Massachusetts Democrats Panicking over a Special Election
Nov20 Conservative Republicans Fight Back
Nov20 Saxby Chambliss May Face a Primary Challenge
Nov20 West Tosses in the Towel
Nov20 Eliminating Loopholes Won't Get Us Off the Fiscal Hill
Nov19 Obama's Pollster Dumps on Gallup
Nov19 Rural White Voters Having Trouble Understanding the Election
Nov19 Republicans Want to Avoid More Bitter Primaries
Nov19 Republicans Are Attacking Charlie Crist Already
Nov19 Even after Recount, Allen West Refuses to Concede
Nov19 The End is Near
Nov18 Marco Rubio Now Campaigning in Iowa
Nov18 Republicans Are Warming to Immigration Reform
Nov17 Republican Attacks on Romney Continue Unabated
Nov17 Obama Campaign Was Data Driven
Nov17 Final House Results Are Coming In
Nov17 Congressional Gender Gap Grows
Nov16 Republicans Condemn Romney's Remarks about Gifts
Nov16 What Kind of Candidates Will Jerry Moran Recruit in 2014?
Nov16 Bennet May Take Over DSCC Chairmanship from Patty Murray
Nov16 How Did the Democrats Make Gains in the Senate?
Nov16 Five House Races Still Undecided
Nov15 Senate Republicans: Candidates Matter
Nov15 House Republicans Elect a Woman to Leadership Position
Nov15 Polling Cell phones Is Increasingly a Problem
Nov15 Results of the Poll Taken Here on Nov. 5
Nov15 Gerrymandering for Beginners
Nov15 Immigration Reform Could Help the Democrats in 2014 and 2016
Nov14 Exit Polls Showed Expected Results
Nov14 How Can the Republicans Win Elections Again?
Nov14 Republicans Openly Lobbying for Kerry as Secretary of State
Nov14 Michael Bloomberg To Become a Political Force
Nov14 Jerry Moran Expected to Lead NRSC
Nov14 Final Senate Results
Nov13 Polling for 2014 Gubernatorial Races Has Started
Nov13 Polling for 2016 Democratic Caucuses Has Started
Nov13 Polling for the Iowa Republican Caucuses Has Also Started
Nov13 Goode Didn't Swing Virginia
Nov13 Final Election Results
Nov12 Fight Breaking Out Between Conservative Pundits and Republican Politicians
Nov12 Congress Now Turns Its Attention to the Fiscal Hillock
Nov12 Congress Begins to Address the Voting Process
Nov12 What Happens to Losing Presidential Candidates?
Nov11 Democrats Fear Losing a Senate Seat
Nov11 Conservative Columnist Speaks the Truth about the Election
Nov11 Rundown of Congressional Races by Region
Nov10 Gender Gap Was the Largest Ever Measured